Canadian Capitalist Logo Dark
No Result
View All Result
Friday, March 24, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Markets
  • Real Estate
  • Retirement
  • Tax Savings
  • Trivia
  • Resources
Subscribe
Canadian Capitalist Logo Light
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Markets
  • Real Estate
  • Retirement
  • Tax Savings
  • Trivia
  • Resources
No Result
View All Result
Canadian Capitalist Logo Mobile
No Result
View All Result
Home Uncategorised

Performance of Currency-Neutral S&P 500 Index Funds

by Ram Balakrishnan
January 19, 2014
Reading Time: 4 mins read
127 10
0
when do reits liquidate
157
SHARES
2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linkedin

Many investors would like to get exposure to US stocks in their portfolio even if they believe that the US dollar is in a secular decline against other major currencies. In theory, currency-neutral funds appear to offer the best of both worlds: exposure to one of the world’s most dynamic stock markets without the baggage of the risk of a depreciating currency. However, if you look at the eight year performance history of currency-neutral funds since they were first introduced in 2006, a different reality emerges.

Comparing S&P 500 CAD Hedged Index Fund TSX: XSP with USD-denominated IVV

First, let’s compare the returns of the iShares CDN S&P 500 Hedged to Canadian Dollars Index Fund (TSX: XSP) with the iShares S&P 500 Index Fund (NYSE Arca: IVV) in US dollars. In the following table, the annual total returns in NAV terms of XSP are listed in Column 2 and the total returns of IVV in US dollars are listed in Column 3. The performance between the two funds is compared from 2006 because in 2005 and earlier years, XSP was a clone fund that used derivatives to skirt RRSP foreign content rules. While XSP’s MER of 0.25% is just 18 basis points (0.18%) higher than IVV, the difference in performance (shown in Column 4) is much wider.

A Canadian investor who bought $100 (Canadian) worth of XSP in 2006 would have ended up with $152 at the end of 2011. A US investor who bought $100 (US) worth of IVV, on the other hand, would be left with $175. In other words, the returns in XSP trailed that of IVV by an annualized rate of 1.9%. A Canadian investor who bet that the C$ would appreciate against the USD and opted XSP over IVV would have made the right call but lost money on the bet. The C$ appreciated at an annualized 1.05% against the USD but the tracking error of XSP wiped out all of the gains and then some. Interestingly, a Canadian investor who bought $100 (Canadian) worth of IVV in 2006 would have ended 2013 with $161, which is a total of 6% more than XSP, even though the C$ gained 9% during that time period.

  Year  XSP  IVV (in US$)  Difference
201332.50%32.31%-0.19%
201215.56%15.91%0.35%
20111.07%2.03%0.96%
201013.47%14.97%1.50%
200922.95%26.40%3.45%
2008-40.33%-36.94%3.39%
20073.23%5.43%2.20%
200614.30%15.68%1.38%
Average1.63%

 

Comparing Vanguard Currency-Hedged and USD returns

Vanguard Canada launched the S&P 500 CAD-hedged ETF (TSX: VSP) in 2012. We now have an opportunity to compare its returns with the USD returns of its underlying holding — the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO). As with other products, the currency-hedged ETF slightly outperformed the USD returns in 2013.

  Year  VSP  VOO (in US$)  Difference
201332.62%32.33%-0.29%
Average-0.29%

 

Comparing TD e-Series Currency-Hedged and USD returns

This pattern of the currency-neutral fund exhibiting significant tracking error can also be observed in the TD e-Series index funds. As you can see in the following table, the TD e-Series US Index Currency Neutral fund under performs the TD e-Series US Index (US$) fund by an annualized 1.35%.

  Year  TD US Index (CAD) TDB902  TD US Index Currency Hedged TDB904  TD US Index (USD) TDB952  Difference
201338.62%32.07%31.43%-0.64%
201210.90%15.40%15.20%-0.20%
20114.10%0.30%1.50%1.20%
20108.40%12.60%14.30%1.70%
20096.70%22.20%25.70%3.50%
2008-21.70%-39.00%-37.40%1.60%
2007-11.10%3.10%4.90%1.72%
200614.70%14.00%15.10%1.10%
Average1.26%

 

It is often asked why currency-hedged funds have exhibited such horrendous tracking errors. It turns out that the bulk of the blame can be attributed to the tendency of stocks and currencies to move in opposite directions (See post Why Currency-Hedged Funds have Large Tracking Errors).

So, what should investors do? If past performance is any indication and if investment performance is the only consideration, it appears that investors will likely be better off obtaining direct exposure to foreign equities without hedging away currency exposure. Owning foreign stocks directly has provided better returns in the past and it has done so with lower risk.

Note: This post was first published on Jan 3, 2010. It has since been updated with annual returns until 2013. In 2013, currency hedged funds generally outperformed the underlying funds in local currency terms. Still, the bottom line remains: currency-hedged US Equity funds still lag that local currency returns by a significant margin over the long term.

Related posts:

  1. Finding a Financial Advisor, Part 1
  2. Carnival of Debt Reduction # 19
  3. The Income Tax Cut is Better
  4. This and That
Share63Tweet39Share11

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Why I moved to BMO InvestorLine

Next Post

Sleepy Mini Portfolio Q4-2013 Update

Ram Balakrishnan

Ram Balakrishnan

Related Posts

Why you cant afford a house in Canada

Why You Can’t Afford A Home In Canada?

January 24, 2022
365
investing benefits
Investing

Finding a Financial Advisor, Part 1

June 19, 2021
2.1k
investing in bitcoin

Is it time to invest in Bitcoins again?

May 13, 2019
2k
is mortgage interest tax deductible
Uncategorised

The 2013 Sleepy Portfolio Report Card

January 12, 2014
2k
how to buy individual stocks in canada
Uncategorised

Asset Class Returns for 2013

January 5, 2014
1.9k
trading the fundamentals
Tax Savings

Tax Treatment of ESPP Benefits

October 29, 2013
2.2k
Next Post
what are the best canadian bank stocks to buy

Sleepy Mini Portfolio Q4-2013 Update

Please login to join discussion
Canadian Capitalist

© 2022 Canadian Capitalist

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertisement
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Markets
  • Real Estate
  • Retirement
  • Tax Savings
  • Trivia
  • Resources

© 2022 Canadian Capitalist

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
Sign Up with Linked In
OR

Fill the forms below to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
two man and woman standing on doorway
The man who does not read has no advantage over the man who cannot read - Mark Twain